Janet Frame
Saturday, January 28, 2023
"Between My Father and the King" -A Short Stories by Janet Frame- from Between My Father and the King and Other Stories - 2012
Janet Frame
Monday, August 26, 2019
Beyond the Bay - A Novel by Rebecca Burns - 2018
Monday, September 29, 2014
The Keepsake by Kirsty Gunn
This is an update of a prior post on the occasion of my fourth reading of this great book with a few new observations added at the start.
Notes added after fourth reading
"Parts of The Keepsake somehow brought to mind ancient death cults or Meso-American religion."-from my first post on The Keepsake (in September 2011)
This is my third reading of a very amazing almost painfully beautiful very dark book, The Keepsake by Kirsty Gunn (1960, New Zealand). I hope to read it a number of more times.
There is so much in this book it is hard for me to know where to start. I found reading it the third time a very intense experience as I feel I am beginning to come to terms with the work.
Here is the goodreads description of the book (almost never do I quote third party descriptions but I need help here)
Through a shifting and interwoven narrative, Kirsty Gunn explores the dark world of a young girl who has grown up with a mother dependent on storytelling and the oblivion of addiction to cope with the memory of her lost love, the girl's father. Raised on these deceptive tales of happiness, the younger woman is drawn into and begins to relive the real story of pain, abandonment, and the tyranny of desire. Her shocking affair with an older man seems to repeat the pattern set by her mother. The tangled yarn of her mother's past begins to be unraveled by the younger woman - until finally she can come to tell a story that is her.
Friday, May 23, 2014
"The Bull Calf" by Rachel Fenton (2013)
Rachel J. Fenton was born in 1976 and grew up in relative poverty in South Yorkshire. She has a BA in English Studies from Sheffield Hallam University, where she studied under the tutelage of E. A. Markham before relocating to Auckland in 2007. Winner of the 7th Annual Short Fiction Competition (University of Plymouth) and the 2013 Flash Frontier Winter Award, she is a Pushcart Prize nominee. Short-listed for the 2013 Fish international Poetry Prize (judged by Paul Durcan), the 2012 Royal Society of New Zealand Manhire Prize, Binnacle Ultra-Short Competition (named honoree), the Fish One Page Prize, the 6th Annual Short Fiction Competition, and the Kathleen Grattan Award, other listings include the Bristol Prize, and the Sean O’ Faolain International Short Story Prize.
Recent publications include the journals The Stinging Fly Magazine; Short Fiction #7;JAAM #30, #31; brief #44-45, #47; French Literary Review #18; Cordite Poetry Review;Pank; and Metazen; and a comprehensive list can be found at http://snowlikethought.
AKA Rae Joyce, she is an AUT award winning graphic poet, was mentored by Dylan Horrocks, is featured in New Zealand Comics and Graphic Novels (Hicksville Press), Two Thirds North, The Poetry Bus, Flash Frontier, Thrush Poetry Journal, and was 2013 Artist in Residence at Counterexample Poetics. Between 2011 and 2012, she wrote, drew and published a page per day of the epic web-comic Escape Behaviours.
As the story opens the Prime Minister of New Zealand intended to announce in a press release that he was starting a new "pest control" policy, instead he made a mistake and said "pet control". The policy went on to detail how he planned to get rid of all of New Zealand's pets. Everybody expected the prime minister would acknowledge an error, maybe blame it on an underling. Instead he won't admit he was wrong. I want to quote a bit from the story so you can get a feel for Fenton's superb prose which perfectly matches her story.
"The way the Prime Minister talked, you’d have thought he was a conservationist, some even suggested comparison to higher posts. Maybe that’s how it got so far; people forgot he was only a politician. He went on.
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
The Big Music by Kirsty Gunn (2012, 496 pages)
Monday, October 15, 2012
The Unlife of Ma Parker by Matt and Debbie Cowens A Short Story
Not long ago I posted on a wonderful collection of short stories, Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon by Matt and Debbie Cowens (2012, 232 pages). The stories are presented to us as newly discovered Mansfield stories that show her great interest in paranormal matters. I loved the book and the stories were all wonderful and a lot of fun. I think Katherine Mansfield would have liked them and I am sure John Middleton Murry would have demanded royalities and claim he was planning to publish these stories soon if he were still with us. One of my favorite Katherine Mansfield stories is "The Life of Ma Parker." I am very honored that Matt and Debbie Cowens have allowed me to share this wonderful story with my readers."The Unlife of Ma Parker"
Tuesday, opened the door to her that morning, he asked after her grandson.
Ma Parker stood on the doormat inside the dark little hall, and she
stretched out her hand to help her gentleman shut the door before she
replied. The skin on the back of her hand had a greenish, sickly pallor and
a line of stitches peeped out from under the cuff of her coat. "He's
breathing easier now, sir," she said quietly before tugging her coat sleeves
back down to her knuckles.
"Oh... good! I'm delighted to hear that," said the literary gentleman.
In spite of the good news, Ma Parker looked worse than usual. Any trace of
colour had withered away, leaving only sallow grey skin and unsettlingly
pale eyes staring out of dark and swollen eyelids. A worn, greasy scarf was
wrapped about her neck, bulging at each side as some hidden bulk forced it
out. But he felt awkward. He could hardly go back to the warm sitting-room
without saying something―something more. Then because her sort set such a
store by the meanest sorts of education he said kindly, "The young lad will
be in school soon?"
"Beg parding, sir?" said old Ma Parker huskily.
Poor old bird! She did look dashed. "I hope the boy will begin, ah,
school," said he. Ma Parker gave no answer. She bent her head and hobbled
off to the kitchen, clasping the old fish bag that held her cleaning things
and an apron and a pair of felt shoes. The literary gentleman raised his
eyebrows and went back to his breakfast.
"Taken ill, I suppose," he said aloud, helping himself to the marmalade.
There was no other explanation for her strange behaviour and disturbing
appearance.
Ma Parker drew the two jetty spears out of her bag and hung it behind
the door. She unhooked her worn jacket and hung that up too. Then she tied
her apron and sat down to take off her boots. To take off her boots or to
put them on was an agony to her, but she had been in agony for days. In
fact, she was so accustomed to the pain that her face was drawn and screwed
up ready for the twinge before she'd so much as untied the laces. That over,
she sat back with a sigh and softly rubbed the stitches above her ankles.
The feet which were now attached to her legs were larger than her own had
been and concealing them under the boots had made the pain so much worse,
but what else was she to do?
*
"Gran! Gran!" Her little grandson stood on her lap in his button boots.
He'd just come in from playing in the street.
"Look what a state you've made your gran's skirt into!"
But he put his arms round her neck and rubbed his cheek against hers.
"Gran, gi' us a penny!" he coaxed.
"Be off with you; Gran ain't got no pennies."
"Yes, you 'ave."
"No, I ain't."
"Yes, you 'ave. Gi' us one!"
Already she was feeling for the old, squashed, black leather purse.
"Well, what'll you give your gran?"
He gave a shy little laugh and pressed closer. She felt his eyelid
quivering against her cheek. "I ain't got nothing," he murmured...
*
The old woman heaved her body upright, seized the iron kettle off the
gas stove and took it over to the sink. The noise of the water drumming in
the kettle deadened her pain, it seemed. She filled the pail, too, and the
washing-up bowl. The extra tendons the doctor had inserted into her forearms
made light work of the lifting, but the weakness in her chest prevented her
from taking any pleasure in it.
It would take a whole book to describe the state of that kitchen. During
the week the literary gentleman "did" for himself. That is to say, he
emptied the tea leaves now and again into a jam jar set aside for that
purpose, and if he ran out of clean forks he wiped over one or two on the
roller towel. Otherwise, as he explained to his friends, his "system" was
quite simple, and he couldn't understand why people made all this fuss about
house-keeping.
"You simply dirty everything you've got, get a hag in once a week to
clean up, and the thing's done."
The result looked like a gigantic dustbin. Even the floor was littered
with decaying toast crusts, envelopes, cigarette ends. But Ma Parker bore
him no grudge. She pitied the poor young gentleman for having no one to
look after him. Out of the smudgy little window you could see a dark
alleyway with a thin strip of sad-looking sky, and whenever there were
clouds they looked very worn, old clouds, frayed at the edges, with holes in
them, or dark stains like tea.
While the water was heating, Ma Parker began sweeping the floor. "Yes,"
she thought, as the broom knocked, "what with one thing and another I've had
my share. I've had a hard life."
Even the neighbours said that of her. Many a time, hobbling home with
her fish bag she heard them, waiting at the corner, or leaning over the area
railings, say among themselves, "She's had a hard life, has Ma Parker." And
it was so true she wasn't in the least proud of it. It was just as if you
were to say she lived in the basement-back at Number 27. She'd had a hard
life, but now? Now what did she have...?
*
At sixteen she'd left Stratford and come up to London as a kitchen-maid.
Yes, she was born in Stratford-on-Avon. Shakespeare? No, people were always
asking her about him. But she'd never heard his name until she saw it on
the theatres.
Nothing remained of Stratford except that "sitting in the fire-place of
an evening you could see the stars through the chimney," and "Mother always
'ad 'er side of bacon, 'anging from the ceiling." And there was something―a
plant, there was―at the front door, that smelt ever so nice. But the plant
was very vague. She'd only remembered it once or twice just before the
operation, when she was lain out like a corpse on the table and the gas
filled her lungs....
It had been a dreadful place―her first place. She was never allowed out.
She never went upstairs except for prayers morning and evening. It was a
fair cellar. And the cook was a cruel woman. She used to snatch away her
letters from home before she'd read them, and throw them in the range
because they made her dreamy.
When that family was sold up she went as "help" to a doctor's house, and
after two months there, she married her husband. He had been a baker and she
had been desperate to leave the doctor's house. The doctor had scared her
from the first day. He wasn't a cruel man; he was kind in his own strange
way but she had been terrified by those unnatural experiments in the
attic...
"A baker, Mrs Parker!" the literary gentleman would say. For
occasionally he laid aside his tomes and lent an ear, at least, to this
product called Life. "It must be rather nice to be married to a baker!"
Mrs Parker didn't look so sure.
"Such a clean trade," said the gentleman.
Mrs Parker didn't look convinced.
"And didn't you like handing the new loaves to the customers?"
"Well, sir," said Mrs Parker, "I wasn't in the shop above a great deal.
We had thirteen little ones and buried seven of them. If it wasn't the
'ospital it was the infirmary, you might say!"
"You might, indeed, Mrs Parker!" said the gentleman, shuddering, and
taking up his pen again.
Yes, seven had gone, and while the six were still small her husband was
taken ill with consumption. It was flour on the lungs, the doctor told her
at the time.... Her husband sat up in bed with his shirt pulled over his
head, and the doctor's finger drew a circle on his back.
"Now, if we were to cut him open here, Mrs Parker," said the doctor,
"you'd find his lungs chock-a-block with white powder. Breathe, my good
fellow!" And Mrs Parker never knew for certain whether she saw or whether
she fancied she saw a great fan of white dust come out of her poor dead
husband's lips....
But the struggle she'd had to bring up those six little children and
keep herself to herself. Terrible it had been! Then, just when they were old
enough to go to school her husband's sister came to stop with them to help
things along, and she hadn't been there more than two months when she fell
down a flight of steps and hurt her spine. And for five years Ma Parker had
another baby―and such a one for crying! ―to look after. Then young Maudie
went wrong and took her sister Alice with her; the two boys emigrated, and
young Jim went to India with the army, and Ethel, the youngest, married a
good-for-nothing little waiter who died of ulcers the year little Lennie was
born. And little Lennie―her poor little grandson. She would have done
anything for him....
*
The piles of dirty cups, dirty dishes, were washed and dried. The
ink-black knives were cleaned with a piece of potato and finished off with a
piece of cork. The table was scrubbed, and the dresser and the sink that
had old sardine tails swimming in it....
*
Lennie had never been a strong child―never from the first. He'd been one
of those fair babies that everybody took for a girl. Silvery fair curls he
had, blue eyes, and a little freckle like a diamond on one side of his
nose. The trouble she and Ethel had had to rear that child! The things out
of the newspapers they tried him with! Every Sunday morning Ethel would
read aloud while Ma Parker did her washing.
"Dear Sir, Just a line to let you know my little Myrtil was laid out for
dead... After four bottles... gained 8 lbs. in 9 weeks, and is still putting
it on."
And then the egg-cup of ink would come off the dresser and the letter
would be written, and Ma would buy a postal order on her way to work next
morning. But it was no use. Nothing made little Lennie put it on. Taking
him to the cemetery, even, never gave him a colour; a nice shake-up in the
bus never improved his appetite.
But he was gran's boy from the first....
"Whose boy are you?" said old Ma Parker, straightening up from the stove
and going over to the smudgy window. And a little voice, so warm, so close,
it half stifled her―it seemed to be in her breast under her heart―laughed
out, and said, "I'm gran's boy!"
*
At that moment there was a sound of steps, and the literary gentleman
appeared, dressed for walking.
"Oh, Mrs Parker, I'm going out."
She kept her back to him, rude though it was, for fear he would see her
arms and grow curious. "Very good, sir."
"And you'll find your half-crown in the tray of the inkstand."
"Thank you, sir."
The door banged. She took her brushes and cloths into the bedroom. But
when she began to make the bed, smoothing, tucking, patting, the small lungs
in her chest ached, making the job almost unbearable. She thought of little
Lennie and his suffering. It hadn't been right. That's what she couldn't
understand. Why should a little angel child have to ask for his breath and
fight for it? There had been no sense in making a child suffer like that.
*
A sound as though something was boiling came from Lennie's little box of
a chest. A great lump of something bubbling in his chest that he couldn't
get rid of. When he coughed the sweat sprang out on his head; his eyes
bulged, his hands waved, and the great lump bubbled as a potato knocks in a
saucepan. But what was more awful was when he didn't cough he sat against
the pillow and never spoke or answered, or even made as if he heard. Only he
looked offended.
"It's not your poor old gran's doing it, my lovey," said old Ma Parker,
patting back the damp hair from his little scarlet ears. But Lennie moved
his head and edged away. Dreadfully offended with her he looked―and solemn.
He bent his head and looked at her sideways as though he couldn't have
believed it of his gran.
She couldn't lose Lenny, not while she still had breath in her body. She
went to see the son of her old employer―a doctor, carrying on his father's
work―and asked him about one of those experiments in the attic. She'd been
cleaning when she'd come across it all those years ago―a rabbit pinned to a
tray of wax, severed in half and stitched back up across the belly, and a
large number of wires clamped here and there, and even sewn into the
creature's chest and temples.
"Ah, I see you're admiring my latest patient," the old doctor had
appeared at her shoulder, making her start.
"Sorry, sir, I was only..."
"No, need to apologise. It's fascinating. The power of electricity. We
still know so little about its true potential, but I have been conducting my
experiments and if you'll now observe..." He switched on a contraption by
the table and with a crackle the rabbit jerked in a violent spasm. Then its
little chest moved up and down, and it turned its head ever so slightly
towards her, and blinked...
The doctor's son had carried on his father's work, and seemed excited at
the prospect of some human subjects.
"You understand there'll be risks," he said. "I may be able to get your
lungs into the little boy, but you'll almost certainly perish while I attend
to him. Should the reanimation process then bring you back it may have
serious complications. There's a very real possibility of tissue damage in
the extremities―lower limbs, hands, feet and so on."
"Do whatever it takes, sir. Just help my Lennie."
What was the good of her having a strong pair of lungs in her old body
when little Lennie suffered?
Lennie thrived after the operation and was stronger every day. She had
woken into an unlife of fresh agony. How long would her aching body struggle
on in this wretched state? The doctor had no answers to comfort her. She
had died on the surgeon's table, her body torn open and her lungs removed.
Little Lennie's twisted lungs had filled her chest cavity and some pickled
hands and feet had replaced her own. An intricate clockwork ticked away
beneath her sternum, keeping the dead, foreign body parts in time with the
spark of life that the electricity had rekindled. When she asked him about
the layers of muscle and bone that he had grafted to her healthy limbs, the
doctor had chuckled and said that his curiosity had got the better of him.
*
"What's it matter if Lenny lives and breathes?" she whispered, rubbing
the trail of surgical thread round her throat beneath her collar. The steel
bolts protruding from either side of her neck tingled as her fingers―the
pickled fingers of a long dead woman―brushed against them. Now even the feel
of her boy's warm arms about her neck gave her pain, but she couldn't let
him know that. She couldn't wince at the sharp twinges of the stitching at
her throat, wrists, and ankles. She couldn't let herself cough though the
small lungs in her chest were so clogged that she felt that she might never
breathe clean air again.
"I can't ever let him know."
As she said those words she suddenly let fall her brush and doubled over
in a fit of violent coughing. She found herself in the kitchen, unable to
breathe as though she was drowning in a sea of flour and ash. It was so
terrible that she flung open the back door of the flat, gasping for air. Her
breath caught in her throat at the sight of a man leaning against the wall
in the alleyway. He was tall and thin, a knitted cap pulled low over his
brow and the collar of his worn, dark coat turned up. He smiled at her,
broad yellow teeth showing behind a coarse beard.
"Stuffy in there, eh?" he asked, pushing off from the wall and
swaggering toward her. His right hand was pressed against his leg, and she
saw a sturdy black poker swinging behind his coat. Its sooty end bore a
nasty looking hook.
Ma Parker stepped back into the kitchen without a word and swung the
door shut, but the man lunged forward and thrust the tip of the poker into
the gap. Ma Parker staggered back, her heavy feet clumsy beneath her. The
door swung open and the man stepped into the kitchen, still smiling.
"I saw the gent leave," he said, lifting the poker and resting it on his
shoulder. He looked around the room, picked up a silver salt shaker from the
bench.
"He'll be back any minute, I'm sure," Ma Parker said, backing up against
the door to the hall.
"Oh, I don't know as that's fer certain." The man's smile faded and he
unbuttoned his coat with his left hand and licked his lips. "I reckon
there's like to be plenty of time."
Ma Parker knew she could not run. Even before the surgery she'd moved
slowly. Now she could barely manage more than a shuffle. She straightened
her apron and muttered, "You'd best be on your way."
There were no more words. The man crossed the kitchen in two quick
strides, brought the poker up as high as the low ceiling would allow, and
swung it with deadly force. Ma Parker thought of her little Lennie, his
bright face and scarred chest with her lungs inside, and she smiled.
The poker caught her in the neck. The force of it was terrific―enough to
knock her off her feet. She sprawled onto the kitchen floor and waited for
the darkness to take her. She saw the man step over her then push open the
door to the hall. His feet were enormous. So were his hands.
She was surprised to find that the pain of the blow was quick to fade.
It had ripped fire across her throat when the poker struck, but now it was
back to its dull ache. She raised a hand to her neck and there was blood,
but not the fountain she'd expected. She sat up. Taking a polished pot from
the stove, she inspected her reflection. The bolt on the left side of her
neck was bent and her stitches had pulled, but that was all. She slipped off
the apron and inspected her collar bone. Blood oozed from the scar where the
clockwork had been inserted down into her chest cavity. And yet, she was
alive. Or undead. Whatever the case, the assault had not left her worse for
wear. There was no guarantee that her attacker would leave her unmolested
as he made his exit, though. Ma Parker rose to her feet, looked to the open
door to the alley, hefted the pot, and stepped into the hall.
She found the man in the sitting room, bent over the literary
gentleman's writing desk. Ma Parker stepped into the room and tightened her
grip on the pot handle.
"I've had a hard life," she said. She shuffled forward on tender ankles.
"Hard and brutal and full of grief."
The man turned, his face drawn. His eyes flicked toward the hall, where
his poker rested against the wall, then back to Ma Parker. He looked from
the pot to the neck bolts to the swollen purple scars which crossed her
collar bone and disappeared under her dress.
"There's no need for you to get hurt," he said, raising his calloused
hands, palms open.
"Too late for that," Ma Parker replied, eyeing him up.
"'Ave it your way," the man growled, slipping a short-bladed knife out
of his belt. He tried to circle round her but Ma Parker shuffled back in
front of the doorway.
"That's a nice voice you've got. Must have a good set of lungs in
there."
She shuffled forward, the pot hanging loose from her hand. He fired a
quick rabbit punch into her leering face then brought the knife up in a
thrust intended to slip under her ribcage. It hurt more than she'd expected
as the blade lodged in the extra bones that the doctor had used to reinforce
her chest. She nearly fell, but she managed to get a hold of his coat with
her free hand and steady herself. As he tried to barge past her and reached
for the poker she brought the pot around in an underarm arc and struck him
on the elbow of his outstretched arm. There was a wet crack and the lower
half of his arm swung up, then hung like a meaty pendulum. He would have
screamed, but at that moment she let go of his coat and seized the back of
his head. She meant to crack his forehead against the door frame, but as she
gripped the back of his skull and pulled back in preparation for the blow,
she felt something in her forearm tugging. Ma Parker could feel the new
sinew and bone slipping into place, could feel the strength in her new limb,
muscles yearning to be used. She gave in to the urge.
The back of the man's head burst like a rotten egg. Ma Parker felt her
fingers stretch then puncture the skin at the back of his head as his skull
shattered. He twitched and danced for a moment, then slumped forward into
the hall. Ma Parker looked down at her pickled hand, the tightly corded
muscles in her forearm, the chunk of flesh with matted hair and blood in
her fingers.
"What 'ave I done?" said old Ma Parker.
As she said those words she suddenly let fall her hand. She stumbled
back into the kitchen, as though by leaving the hall she could escape her
actions.
She couldn't go home; Lennie was there. The blood would frighten Lennie
out of his life. She couldn't go outside and sit on a bench anywhere; people
would come asking questions. If she even sat on the doorstep a policeman
might come by and speak to her.
Wasn't there anywhere where she could hide and keep herself to herself
and stay as long as she liked, not disturbing anybody, and nobody noticing
her?
Her chin began to tremble; there was no time to lose.
She shuffled back to the hall with her heavy mop and bucket. "Nothing
fer it. I'll have to clean this mess up."
When the literary gentleman returned he found that the hallway carpet
was quite wet, and faintly pink. Methods of cleaning being a mystery to him
he thanked Ma Parker, who had stayed unusually late, but asked her to be
less vigorous with the furnishings in future. She nodded as she left, her
clumsy feet and shuffling gait as pitiful as ever. She didn't seem overly
troubled by the enormous bundle she carried over her shoulder, something
angular and bulky wrapped in two wet coats. She coughed up a gob of blood as
she left, but it didn't seem to trouble her much.
"Fresh," she muttered to herself as she stepped out into the biting
wind. "Head's no use, but still plenty of good parts left."
It was cold on the street as she began her long journey to the doctor's
house. People went flitting by, very fast; the men walked like scissors; the
women trod like cats, but nobody paid any notice to the shuffling old woman
with the heavy bundle.
The icy wind swept up the street and blew out her apron into a balloon.
And now it began to rain.
Monday, October 1, 2012
Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon by Matt and Debbie Cowens
Matt and Debbie Cowens in Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon have seen beyond the Mansfield of society ladies in conferences, beyond the New Zealand patriots, beyond those who read her work because of what Virginia Woolf said about her. They show a deep insight into a darker side of her psyche and work not found in too many other places. The stories in this collection are purported to be the correct versions of some of the most famous stories of Mansfield, before they were censored.
I have read and posted on all of the short stories of Katherine Mansfield (1888 to 1923-New Zealand) that can be found online. My knowledge of the life of Katherine Mansfield mainly comes from the magisterial biography by Kathleen Jones, Katherine Mansfield-The Story Teller. In their very interesting and plausible introduction the Cowens tell us that Mansfield had a strong interest in occult matters. She was acquainted with Aleister Crowley (occultists will not like this but I think much of the occult practices and beliefs in the English speaking world found today and for sure during the life of Mansfield, can be traced to the writings of Crowley.) The introduction of the Cowens tells us more about her relationship with Crowley and other occult figures than Jones does (Jones probably left them out as these are speculative conjectures at least in part). I was very interested to learn that in her travels in Europe she often stopped at occult pilgrimage places. If you study her relationships with men she seems to have a pattern of involvement with Guru like men. If you wanted to you could probably trace this in part back to her relationship with her very powerful and dominating father. Seances, mystics, Eastern Europeans cult leaders, spirit readings and such were all the rage in Mansfield's time in England and Europe (1903 to 1933). It is perfectly credible to see Mansfield as having a deep interest in such things. She was, however,nobody's fool so I will let the scholars ponder the question if they like but my Katherine Mansfield was knowledgeable about the occult and may have turned to it as she sensed her early death was approaching.
The stories in Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon are brilliant, quite wonderful retellings of the most famous of Mansfield's short stories as if they were tales from the dark side. They are so well done that they do feel just like she wrote them. There are seventeen stories in this collection. I really liked every one. Some are laugh out loud funny and some are beautiful. Mansfield's stories are often about lonely left out people and these stories capture that. I will post a bit on seven of the stories so you can get a feel for the collection and will then make a few concluding remarks. I will also include a link to the publishers web page on the book where you can learn a lot more about it, read comments from well known critics on it and see pictures of the authors as well as a well done video. You can also download a sample of the work.
"Mrs Brill" ("Miss Brill" is the most read of Mansfield's stories-I can sort of tell based on visits to my web pages on her work which of her stories is being read-and taught-anywhere in the world) is a hilarious retelling of a classic story. In the much loved original, Miss Brill takes her fox wrap with her to the park and observes the people around her and talks to the fox head about them. She sees herself as above the to her dull and mundane people in the park. Then one day something happens that breaks her heart. This story is about Mrs Brill, the original Brill had as far as we know no men in her life ever, is similar but ever so different. Mr Brill is basically dead but she is able to reanimate him twice a year and she always takes him to the park to talk to about the people they see. The ending of this story is both totally funny, works perfectly as a tale of revenge and is quite logical. I will leave it untold.
"The Fly" (some consider this her most "existential story"-older men as a general rule do not come off well in her stories-Daddy issues?) starts out very much like the original. An older man is allowed out on his own only once and a while by his very protective family. He often goes to visit his old boss, another older man. The boss has been morose and sad since his son died in a war. In Mansfield's time, (her beloved brother died in WWI) death of young men hung heavy in the air. What is so great about this story is how we gradually learn the son died in a war against alien invaders. We have to figure out for ourselves what happened. I loved this story and I am not sure, blasphemy here, that I did not prefer it to the original.
Everybody likes "The Garden Party", Mansfield's great story about social classes and a young girl's first immersion into the "real world". Some see it as retelling of the Orpheus myth and I find this credible. The story is set inside the walled compound of an affluent family. Outside of the walls are the homes of the poor, seen as less than fully human by the girl's high society money. There is a big change in this story, weird insect like creatures lurk out side the walls and we feel the decay and sadness in the poor. The story, this one and the original, both let us see the eyes of the girl begin to open. This was a really fun story.
The Cowens' version of "The Young Girl" is just toooo weird for words. I think Mansfield would have loved this one. One of the things I like about the stories of the Cowens' is that they do not explain things, they just let the actions and words in the story do their work. I will say is that of alien leaches invaded New Zealand in 1905 or so this story captures it. This is a really wonderful story. Like the others, it is great fun to read.
"A Bank Holiday" is an impressionistic story seemingly set in small town New Zealand on a Bank Holiday (Mansfield's father was chairmen of The Bank of New Zealand). The new version and the old one both give us a good look at what happens during a holiday festival. I loved these lines from the Covens' story:
"He thinks of Egypt, of the risen dead he fought in his youth. He thinks of the great walking gods of Africa, taller than mountains, which drove so many of his companions to madness. He remembers the ecstasy cults of Calcutta who tore themselves to pieces in moments of religious fervour. He hears the Music too, and knows it. It is the cold piping of the deepest recesses of the night, of the place beyond the stars where only hunger reigns. He knows this tide cannot be stopped, cannot be fought. He turns and flees, praying that he might survive the coming terror. Praying that the world will survive."I will just say the bank holiday does not end well.
"The Daughters of the Lizard Colonel" is one of Mansfield's post popular stories. It shows how three adult daughters of a retired colonel are kept in kind of a perpetual state of childhood by its domination. Now imagine the colonel is a lizard creature trying to pass as human and you have a small idea of how great the remade version of this story is.
"The Doll's House" is normally described as a story about class distinctions in rural New Zealand early 20th century. The rich and the poor go to school together but there are lots of class lines. One girl gets a faboulos doll house as a gift and the poorest lowest down family in the community is not allowed to have their daugters view it. You will like the new ending of this story.
There are ten more stories in the collection so I think the Cowens have given solid value.
This is not just a collection of short stories. The whole thing is a really interesting work of art. The introduction makes the stories plausible and there are some very interesting photographs.
I think these stories can be enjoyed by those not into Mansfield but will really be relished by Mansfield devotees like myself (if they can avoid being peeved over the idea behind the stories). Mansfield had kind of a warped sensbility and I think she would have liked these stories and I am sure John Middleton Murry would have demanded royalties!
For a lot more information on Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon go to the web page of the publisher, Steampress
I will be posting an incredible retelling of "The Life of Ma Parker" on my blog in a few days.
Mansfield with Monsters: The Untold Stories of a New Zealand Icon by Matt and Debbie Cowens is a totally fun, wonderfully written and very perceptive collection of stories. You can tell the Cowens loved writing these stories and I loved reading them
Mel u
Featured Post
Imperial Reckoning: The Untold Story of Britain’s Gulag in Kenya by Caroline Elkins - 2005 - 701 Pages
Imperial Reckoning: The Untold Story of Britain’s Gulag in Kenya by Caroline Elkins - 2005 - 701 Pages 2006 Pulitzer Prize Winner From...
-
Book Blogger Appreciation Week Sept 13 to Sept 17-2010-Giveaway- Katherine Wish by Linda Lappin Leave a comment to win! Open to all f...
-
Nothing Can Destroy the Faith and Strength of the people of the Philippines -Mel u, November 10, 2013- comments welcome. "How My B...
-
The Reading Life Guide to Getting Started in the Indian Short Story One of my reading hopes for this year is to read a large number of the s...










.jpg)